Joe Burrow Leads PFF's 2026 Midseason WAR Rankings Across the NFL
Published
Nov 12, 2026
Desk
Football
Views
745
Joe Burrow leads all quarterbacks in PFF's midseason Wins Above Replacement rankings, shaping early All-Pro and MVP conversations across the NFL.
Burrow leads a crowded midseason race
Joe Burrow is setting the pace in PFF’s Wins Above Replacement, with 2.63 WAR—nearly half a win more than any other quarterback. The position leaders elsewhere include Green Bay safety Evan Williams, who tops the league in coverage grade, and Cleveland defenders Quincy Williams and Denzel Ward, currently the most valuable linebacker and cornerback. Those rankings put the Packers and Browns’ defenses in the spotlight.
The 2026 NFL regular season has crossed its halfway mark, and the awards conversation is already taking shape. Individual performance can be measured in plenty of ways, from EPA per play and PFF grade to basic production totals. PFF’s Wins Above Replacement metric tries to combine those dimensions: it accounts for positional value and season-long impact, while factoring in snap volume and overall success.
WAR offers a useful way to compare players whose jobs look nothing alike. It also has limits: the number alone doesn’t explain how a player is producing his value. Still, the leaders at each position provide an early read on who could feature in January’s All-Pro selections. Here are the top five at quarterback, running back, receiver and tight end at the midpoint of the season.
Burrow’s lead is backed by the strongest qualifying marks at the position: a 93.7 overall PFF grade and a 92.5 passing grade. That puts his first MVP award within reach. Prescott has moved the chains more than anyone at quarterback, with 125 first downs. Stroud and Young have each kept their turnover-worthy play rate at 1.2% or lower, the best figures among qualified passers. Cousins, now with Minnesota, ranks eighth in both positively and negatively graded play rates. The field is varied; Burrow’s separation is not.
Walker arrives in Week 10 as the league’s highest-graded running back, with a 90.2 rushing grade and an 87.4 receiving grade. Gibbs and Robinson remain among the position’s five best at forcing missed tackles. Warren’s rise is especially striking: his 91.1 rushing grade leads the NFL, as do his 4.14 yards after contact per carry and 14.2 extra yards per reception. Hubbard has rebounded, forcing 29 missed tackles and logging 16 explosive runs, both eighth-most.
Smith-Njigba is building a case for another Offensive Player of the Year honor. He leads receivers in PFF receiving grade at 92.9 and yards per route run at 3.49. Higgins is making a case of his own after years of being underrated: he ranks sixth in yards per route run at 2.71 and has been effective against man coverage. Chase, Olave and Lamb each rank sixth or better in receiving grade, extending the high level they’ve sustained year after year.
Bowers, Kittle and McBride are familiar names among the top tight ends, and all three appear in this midseason group. Bowers leads the position with a 90.4 overall PFF grade; Kittle sits eight points behind in second. Otton’s third-place WAR ranking is less obvious, but his 71.7 pass-blocking grade ranks fourth among qualified tight ends. Likely has made his new Giants deal look well spent: he’s recorded 27 first downs, third-most at the position, while dropping just one pass.
Where the tight ends actually land
Plot the tight ends on a single grid, with positive graded-play rate on one axis and negative on the other, and the picture gets messy fast. Most of the group clusters between roughly 5% and 9% on the positive side, but the negative numbers spread much wider. That spread is where the interesting players sit.
Charlie Woerner of the Falcons is the outlier at the top of the scale, posting a 10.1% positive rate and a 10.7% negative rate. Eli Raridon (Patriots, 8.2% and 10.5%) and Tommy Tremble (Panthers, 8.7% and 11.2%) show the same pattern: lots of graded plays in both directions. Colby Parkinson (Rams, 8.4% and 11.2%) isn't far behind. If you're scouting for volatility rather than consistency, these are the names to watch.
Pat Freiermuth (Steelers, 8.3% positive, 3.7% negative) and Mark Andrews (Ravens, 8.5% and 5.4%) sit on the opposite side of the chart. Their positive rates are strong and their negative rates are comparatively low. Hunter Henry (Patriots, 6.9% and 3.4%) and Chigoziem Okonkwo (Commanders, 4.9% and 4.9%) are the quieter end of the group, though Okonkwo's numbers are more balanced than his position on the chart suggests.
Sam LaPorta (Lions, 8.6% and 7.4%) and AJ Barner (Seahawks, 9.1% and 7.2%) have the best positive rates in the set, but both also carry real negative exposure. Kyle Pitts (Falcons, 5.8% and 9.1%) is the reverse case: his negative rate is high while his positive rate lags the group.
The harder question is what these rates measure. The chart labels the metric "graded plays" but doesn't say how a play earns a positive or negative grade, or whether the sample sizes are comparable across players. Without that, you can read the ranking, but you can't yet tell whether a 10% negative rate reflects bad play or a heavier role in the offense. Treat the chart as a starting point for questions, not a verdict.
Where tight ends actually help and hurt
Tight end grades are usually reduced to a single number, which hides the more useful story. Premium Stats Pro's positional data splits each player's graded plays into positive and negative shares, and the gap between those two numbers tells you more than either one alone.
Start with the scatter plot. Each player sits on a grid where the horizontal axis tracks how often he makes a positive play and the vertical axis tracks how often he makes a negative one. The most useful players sit low and to the right. The outliers are the ones that make the picture interesting.
Dawson Knox of the Bills is the clearest example of a player who's easy to misread. His positive rate, 6.8%, is respectable, but his negative rate of 11.5% is one of the highest on the chart. Brock Wright of the Lions is in a similar spot, with a 4.1% positive rate against an 11.6% negative rate. Drew Sample of the Bengals lands in the same zone at 5.1% and 10.9%. If you're evaluating a depth tight end, those numbers should make you pause before you call him a reliable blocker.
Then there's the group that's harder to pin down. Tyler Higbee (6.2% positive, 5.9% negative) and Evan Engram (3.3% positive, 3.0% negative) both have low rates across the board. That's not necessarily a red flag. It can mean a player simply doesn't touch the ball or block in ways that generate many graded plays, and the data doesn't fully say which is happening.
The top of the ranking
The leaderboard tells a more pointed story. T.J. Hockenson of the Vikings leads all 39 tight ends with a 10.5% positive rate, but he's 28th in negative rate at 8.0%. Darnell Washington of the Steelers is second in positive rate at 10.4%, yet he's 25th on the negative side at 7.5%. Hockenson and Washington are productive, but they're also boom-or-bust in ways the headline grade doesn't show.
Brock Bowers of the Raiders is the cleanest profile here. He ranks sixth in positive rate at 9.4% and first in negative rate at just 1.3%, which means he rarely hurts his team on a graded snap. Isaiah Likely of the Giants (8.6% positive, 3rd-best 3.1% negative) and George Kittle of the 49ers (9.8% positive, 5.4% negative) also look strong on both counts.
Here's the thing: a low negative rate and a high positive rate are both rare, and the players who combine them are the ones teams should be paying attention to. Bowers and Likely show that pairing. Hockenson and Washington show that a high ceiling and a high floor are different things.
If you want to dig further, the full dataset is sortable on each team's Leaders tab. That's where you'll find out whether a player's numbers hold up over a larger sample, and whether a single bad week is distorting the chart.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.