Zakee Wheatley leads qualifying NFL rookies through Week 9 with a 90.2 PFF grade, and defenders hold the top seven spots.

Nine weeks in, the rookie class has sorted itself out, and the defense is setting the pace. Seven of the 15 highest-graded first-year players are defenders, and they hold the top seven spots. Offense doesn't show up until No. 8. Several first-round picks are in the mix, but the strongest grades are coming from players who got on the field early and stayed there.
The bar here is 20 snaps per game, or 180 across the first nine weeks. That filter keeps out the players who've only sampled a few series, so the list reflects real workloads.
Defense sets the tone
The Carolina Panthers' Zakee Wheatley is the clear leader. His 90.2 PFF grade is the only mark above 90.0 among qualifying rookies, and he's done it in a rotational role. He has 28 tackles and assists, seven of them ending in defensive stops, plus a forced fumble, an interception and two pass breakups. For a player who isn't a full-time starter, that's a lot of production.
Right behind him is Cleveland's Emmanuel McNeil-Warren, who sits at 84.2. He's had a bumpy stretch lately. Two of his three lowest-graded games of the season came in the last two weeks, against the Pittsburgh Steelers and New Orleans Saints, where he earned 60.9 and 60.6. He missed a tackle in both games, and he's now missing 10.0% of his tackle attempts on the season. That's a number to watch, because the second-round pick's coverage grade has carried him this far.
New England's Gabe Jacas is the most productive pass rusher on the list. He's logged 26 pressures on 181 pass-rushing snaps, and eight of those have been sacks or quarterback hits. Jacas kept it going in the Patriots' loss to the Green Bay Packers, adding three more pressures.
Kansas City's Mansoor Delane (79.7) has been quiet since the Chiefs' Week 7 game against Seattle, but his season holds up. Across 176 coverage snaps, he's allowed 14 catches for 227 yards, and he has an interception and four pass breakups. Pittsburgh's Robert Spears-Jennings (78.7) has been steady at safety. He missed just 4.5% of his tackle attempts through nine weeks, and he had a strong showing in the Steelers' Week 8 win over Cleveland even though Pittsburgh had a bye in Week 9.
The New York Giants' Arvell Reese (78.2) had his best game of the season against the Philadelphia Eagles, registering a career-high nine defensive stops, including three sacks. He's still a work in progress in coverage, but he's been a factor against both the run and the pass. Los Angeles' Akheem Mesidor (78.2) set a career high with five pressures on 31 pass-rushing snaps in the Chargers' loss to Houston. He has 17 total pressures, 10 of them sacks or quarterback hits, across 172 rushing snaps.
Dallas safety Caleb Downs (71.9) rounds out the defensive group with the best game of his young career. In the Cowboys' overtime win over Indianapolis, he played 41 coverage snaps, broke up a pass, came away with the game-sealing interception and recorded a sack.
Receivers and the Browns' youth movement
The offensive side of the board is led by receivers, and Cleveland is the team to watch. Denzel Boston leads all rookies with 507 receiving yards through Week 9. He caught six passes for 98 yards against New Orleans in a Week 9 overtime loss, and he's dropped just 3.0% of catchable targets. His 70.3 PFF receiving grade is solid, though it's the volume that stands out.
Teammate KC Concepcion (69.4) had another strong game in the Browns' loss to New Orleans, catching four of six targets for 85 yards and scoring his first NFL touchdown. The Browns' rookie offense has real juice, even if the results haven't followed yet.
The New York Jets' Omar Cooper Jr. (75.1) is the highest-ranked receiver on the list. He missed some time early but has now played enough snaps to qualify, and he's averaging 2.73 yards per route run, which is one of the better marks among rookies. In the loss to Kansas City last week, he caught eight of nine targets for 58 yards.
Miami's Caleb Douglas (74.6) set a career high with six receptions in the Dolphins' loss to Detroit. He's averaging 2.26 yards per route run, and his 74.6 receiving grade has him right in the thick of things.
Washington's Antonio Williams is the cautionary tale. He's coming off the worst game of his young career, a 50.9 PFF grade in the Commanders' loss to the Rams. He dropped his first pass of the season and managed only 25 receiving yards on five targets. He's still at 70.7 on the season, but one bad week can move a rookie down the board quickly.
Jacksonville tight end Nate Boerkircher (68.7) started slowly but has picked up the pace. He caught three passes for 92 yards across wins over Indianapolis and Baltimore.
The offensive line problem
Cleveland's Spencer Fano (74.5) is the one lineman on the list, and he's a split story. Of the 28 pressures he's allowed as a rookie, 14 have come in the last two weeks. Against New Orleans, he gave up a sack, two quarterback hits and three hurries over 46 pass-blocking snaps. He had a good day as a run blocker, earning a 71.6 PFF run-blocking grade, but the pass protection is a real concern if it keeps trending this way.
Here's the thing: the defensive dominance at the top of this list says more about the 2026 draft class than about any one team. Wheatley, Jacas and Mesidor are producing now, not in some future projection. The question for the next nine weeks is whether the receivers and blockers can close the gap, and whether the grades hold when the snap counts go up.

Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.