InvestmiriaCorrespondents · Reports · Analysis
CORRESPONDENT REPORTFootball

Burrow Tops PFF's Midseason NFL All-Pro Team at Quarterback

Published
Nov 12, 2026
Desk
Football
Views
400

Joe Burrow leads PFF's midseason All-Pro QB grades by 8 points over C.J. Stroud, with Smith-Njigba and Walker III also making first team.

Burrow Tops PFF's Midseason NFL All-Pro Team at Quarterback

Burrow sets the pace at quarterback

At the NFL season’s midpoint, Joe Burrow is the clear first-team choice at quarterback. The Cincinnati Bengals passer has a 92.5 PFF passing grade among quarterbacks with at least 150 dropbacks—eight points ahead of the next player. His 20.7% positively graded play rate and 5.4% negatively graded play rate also lead the position. C.J. Stroud of the Houston Texans gets the second-team spot.

The gap makes this more than a close call: Burrow’s advantage shows up in both his best plays and his avoidance of mistakes. The wider All-Pro picture is less settled. Several positions are crowded, and the selections reflect performance through nine weeks, as though the season ended today.

This is the first season PFF’s newer metrics have been available through PFF Premium Stats Pro. They add context at some positions, though the figures don’t explain every selection on their own. Here are the midseason first and second teams.

Offense

Running back

Kenneth Walker III of the Kansas City Chiefs takes the first-team spot in a tight three-player race. Among backs with at least 40 carries, his 91.7 overall PFF grade leads the group, as does his 0.16 wins above replacement. Bijan Robinson of the Atlanta Falcons narrowly misses the teams; Jahmyr Gibbs of the Detroit Lions is second team.

Wide receivers

Jaxon Smith-Njigba of the Seattle Seahawks is PFF’s current pick for Offensive Player of the Year, and his production through nine weeks is already beyond his award-winning 2025 season. He leads all receivers in yards, PFF receiving grade and yards per route run. CeeDee Lamb of the Dallas Cowboys earns the second-team selection.

Christian Watson’s breakout has arrived for the Green Bay Packers. His 2.98 yards per route run ranks third among receivers, behind Smith-Njigba and Mike Evans. Ja’Marr Chase of the Bengals gets the second-team nod.

Tee Higgins rounds out the first-team receiver group after a career year with Cincinnati in 2026. His 91.9 receiving grade trails only Smith-Njigba and Evans, while his 2.71 yards per route run ranks seventh—even as he shares targets with Chase. Drake London of the Falcons is second team.

NFL Wide Receivers
Week 1-9
0.0%10.0%20.0%30.0%40.0%Target Share0.001.002.003.00Yards / Route RunAVGAVG
Evans
Smith
Nacua
Chase
Lamb
Olave
London
Flowers
Burden III
Collins

Volume and efficiency don't travel together

Plot target share against yards per route run and the receiver pool splits in ways a raw catch total hides. Target share tells you how often a quarterback looks a player's way. Yards per route run tells you what happens when he does, across every route, including the ones where he's blocking or standing still. Put both on one chart and the outliers start to talk. Malik Nabers sits in the top corner. He draws 30.3% of targets and posts 2.39 yards per route run, a combination that should worry defensive coordinators. Matthew Golden isn't far behind at 28.0% and 2.45. Those two are the clearest cases of volume and efficiency showing up in the same player. The more interesting story is the mismatch. Michael Wilson commands 27.0% of targets but produces just 1.52 yards per route run. Denzel Boston is similar, at 23.0% share and 1.55 yards. Heavy volume with weak returns usually points to a role or scheme problem, not a talent gap, but a single chart can't tell you which. Then there's Omar Cooper Jr. He sits near the bottom on target share at 8.8%, yet his 2.73 yards per route run is the highest on the plot. Tyquan Thornton (6.4%, 2.23) and Jaylin Noel (8.6%, 2.25) follow the same pattern. Low-volume samples swing hard, so I wouldn't draw a firm conclusion from one season of that. Still, it's a reminder that opportunity and production aren't the same thing. Most of the players cluster between roughly 15% and 25% target share, with efficiency mostly between 1.8 and 2.1 yards per route run. That crowded middle is where the separation gets hard to read. John Metchie III, at 1.18, sits at the floor of the chart. One caveat: the chart doesn't say which season it covers or what minimum route threshold it uses. Those choices change the rankings, so treat the positions as a starting point for questions rather than a verdict.

Volume isn't buying efficiency

Here's the thing about this chart: the receivers with the biggest share of their offense's targets aren't reliably the ones producing the most per route. Malik Washington of the Dolphins leads the plot with a 23.9% target share, but his 1.62 yards per route run is middle-of-the-pack. Stefon Diggs (20.0%, 1.56) and KC Concepcion of the Browns (19.8%, 1.61) follow the same pattern. Heavy involvement, respectable returns, nothing that jumps off the page. Devaughn Vele is a sharper example. The Saints receiver draws 17.6% of targets and posts 1.14 yards per route run, the same rate as Josh Downs of the Colts, who gets a larger share at 18.7%. Both players see plenty of the ball. Neither is moving the efficiency needle much.

The outlier you shouldn't skip past

Ladd McConkey is the name to circle. At a 10.6% target share, he produces 2.23 yards per route run, the best figure on the chart by a clear margin. That's more significant than it looks. He's getting fewer looks than most of this group and generating more per route than anyone in it. Whether that reflects role, scheme, quarterback play, or a small sample, the chart alone can't say. It's not entirely clear why the gap is this wide, and anyone who tells you it's obvious is guessing. Two other names belong in that conversation. Jordan Watkins of the 49ers sits at just 5.9% target share yet posts 1.98 yards per route run, the second-best rate here. Adonai Mitchell of the Jets gets 12.4% of targets and delivers 1.89. Both are doing more with less than their volume would suggest.

Same share, different results

Dontayvion Wicks and Terry McLaurin both sit at an 11.5% target share. Their efficiency splits: Wicks at 1.54, McLaurin at 1.74. Target share alone wouldn't have told you that. Burks, also a Commander, lands at 8.5% share and 1.74 yards per route run, matching McLaurin's rate on fewer targets. That's the case for looking past volume. If you're building projections or scouting depth charts, target share describes how often a receiver is used. It doesn't describe how well he's used, and the gap between those two numbers is where this chart gets interesting.
Source: Gordon McGuinness · www.pff.com

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.