Lions edge rusher Aidan Hutchinson is out for the 2026 season with a torn ACL, leaving Detroit's pass rush with a major hole. His PFF numbers were elite.

The Lions just lost the player holding their pass rush together, and the timing couldn't be worse. Aidan Hutchinson is expected to miss the rest of the 2026 season after tearing his right ACL in Week 10. Detroit has been down this road before, but that doesn't make it any easier to absorb.
- Hutchinson's injury leaves a major hole in Detroit's defense. The Lions edge defender is expected to miss the rest of the 2026 season after tearing his right ACL in Week 10 against the Patriots.
- Elite pass-rushing production will be difficult to replace. Hutchinson leads qualifying edge defenders with a 91.0 PFF pass-rush grade and a 21.9% pass-rush win rate through Week 10.
The injury and what it costs Detroit
Hutchinson hurt himself on a play that should have been a highlight. He was celebrating a sack during the Lions' first defensive series of Week 10 in Munich against the New England Patriots, jumped, and landed awkwardly on his right leg. The fifth-year pass-rusher went down, and the diagnosis came back as a torn ACL.
There's a silver lining, and it's a small one. Further testing reportedly showed no other significant damage. That matters for his long-term outlook, but it does nothing for the 2026 season, and it doesn't soften the loss for a Lions defense that just lost its centerpiece up front.
Head coach Dan Campbell has said he likes the options he has left. That's the expected message. But the PFF numbers make the replacement problem plain. Hutchinson isn't just a good starter who happens to be Detroit's best rusher. He's been among the league's most productive edge defenders since he arrived in 2022.

Elite numbers, and they're not a fluke
Through 10 weeks of 2026, Hutchinson posted a 91.0 pass-rush grade, first among 123 qualifying edge defenders. He generated 52 pressures on 347 pass-rushing snaps: seven sacks, 11 hits and 34 hurries. His 21.9% pass-rush win rate led the position.
Look at the true pass sets and the picture gets sharper. There he earned a 90.4 pass-rush grade, recorded 32 pressures and won 30.4% of his rushes. Those are the situations where a rusher has to beat a blocker on pure talent, with no one guessing about the snap count.
Here's the thing: this isn't a hot streak. Hutchinson has posted a pass-rush grade above 90.0 in each of the past four seasons. Plenty of edge defenders have one great year. Very few string four together.
The career arc, season by season
His rookie year in 2022 was solid rather than spectacular. He posted a 70.2 pass-rush grade, generated 53 pressures and won 12.4% of his rushes. Then 2023 happened. Hutchinson piled up 121 pressures on 718 pass-rushing snaps, the second-most ever recorded by an edge defender in the PFF era, and earned a 91.4 grade that ranked fifth at the position.
2024 was the most dominant stretch of his career, and it was also the shortest. Across just five games before an injury ended his season, he generated 45 pressures and eight sacks on 198 snaps. His 95.0 grade was the best at the position that year, and he won an extraordinary 38.3% of his pass-rushing opportunities.
He came back in 2025 and answered any doubts about the 2024 sample. He finished with 100 pressures, 16 sacks and a 92.1 grade, which ranked fourth among 130 qualifying edge rushers.
| Season | Pass-rush snaps | Pass-rush grade | Rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | 566 | 70.2 | 41 of 129 |
| 2023 | 718 | 91.4 | 5 of 121 |
| 2024 | 198 | 95.0 | 1 of 131 |
| 2025 | 622 | 92.1 | 4 of 130 |
| 2026 | 347 | 91.0 | 1 of 123 |
The table tells the story better than any adjective. He went from a middling rookie to a top-five grade in year two, and he's been at or near the top of the position ever since.
Wins Above Replacement
PFF's WAR numbers add another layer. Hutchinson's wins above replacement by season were 0.21 in 2022 (23rd of 203 edge defenders), 0.67 in 2023 (4th of 186), 0.45 in 2024 (4th of 210), 0.63 in 2025 (2nd of 206) and 0.22 in 2026 (1st of 184). The chart also plots positional averages, which sit well below his peaks in most years.
WAR is a blunt instrument, and a 0.22 in a shortened season doesn't mean much on its own. The trend line is what matters: he's been well above the position for most of four years.
Why the replacement problem is real
Since entering the league in 2022, Hutchinson has produced 371 total pressures, the most among edge defenders over that span. He's also recorded 526 pass-rush wins, 21 more than the next-closest rusher. That's not a small gap at this level.
The race chart below shows the cumulative pass-rush wins from 2022 Week 1 through 2026 Week 10:
- Aidan Hutchinson: 526
- Myles Garrett: 505
- Danielle Hunter: 437
- Micah Parsons: 424
- Josh Hines-Allen: 422
- Maxx Crosby: 395
- Nick Bosa: 391
- Trey Hendrickson: 351
- George Karlaftis: 329
- Will Anderson Jr.: 328
In other words, Detroit isn't just losing its most productive pass-rusher. It's losing the player who has been winning the most individual battles in the league for the better part of four seasons. If you want to see how the numbers stack up against Detroit's other options, the full PFF grades are the place to start, and the Hutchinson profile has the complete breakdown.
A defense already short on answers loses its best edge rusher
Detroit was struggling before Aidan Hutchinson's absence. The Lions rank 25th in EPA allowed per play (+0.06), and the rest of the profile doesn't offer much relief. They're 19th in defensive success rate allowed (45.1%), 22nd in explosive-play rate allowed (14.2%) and 23rd in third-down conversion rate allowed (43.0%).
The high-leverage numbers are worse. Opponents convert at the 22nd-highest rate in the red zone, and Detroit sits 26th in series conversion rate allowed. Those are the snaps that decide close games, and they're the ones where a dominant pass rusher earns his keep. Hutchinson, who has 526 pass-rush wins and leads the league's edge rushers in that category, was exactly that player.
Replacing him is harder than the depth chart suggests. D.J. Wonnum is the next-most productive option, with 19 pressures on 231 pass-rushing snaps and six sacks. That's respectable volume. But his 61.5 pass-rush grade and 12.0% win rate are well below what Hutchinson delivered, and that gap is the real problem. Pressure totals can hide how often a rusher actually beats his blocker, and Wonnum's win rate says he's more of a volume contributor than a difference-maker.
Derrick Moore is the more interesting case. He produced 15 pressures and four sacks on just 118 snaps, and his 12.7% pressure rate is the best of the group. That's a real signal. Still, his 63.3 pass-rush grade and 9.1% win rate suggest the pressures are coming in a smaller role that may not translate to a full workload. If you're tracking this unit, Moore is the name to watch, but he hasn't yet shown he can carry it.
Tyler Lacy has been the least productive of the three. He's generated eight pressures on 109 pass-rushing snaps, with a 61.6 pass-rush grade and a 5.1% win rate. Lacy also carries a questionable tag on the current lineup, which makes his availability a second concern on top of his production.
Put Wonnum, Moore and Lacy together and you get 42 pressures this season. That's 10 fewer than Hutchinson has produced by himself. The combined group is more depth than a single star, but it doesn't add up to the same disruption, and the efficiency numbers suggest the three of them aren't close to replicating what Hutchinson gave this defense on his own.
Campbell isn't sounding the alarm
Campbell's grades-based worries and his public tone don't line up. The PFF depth chart shows the edge group sitting low in the league rankings. Wonnum is 89th of 111 edge defenders, and Derrick Moore ranks 81st of 111. Inside, McNeill (7th of 133 interior linemen) carries the best number on the line, with Williams at 28th. Campbell's response was not to panic.“We still feel pretty good about the edge that we have with (D.J.) Wonnum and Derrick Moore and (Eric) O'Neill, you know,” Campbell said Wednesday. “Then, we'll probably get Ahmed going here a little bit, so we're good.”
That's a confident read for a group that PFF's numbers don't flatter. Coaches often talk up their rotation, and some of that is just the job. But when the public grades and the coach's comments point in different directions, it's fair to ask which one holds up when the games start.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.